Home » Rant » Boston Marathon Suspect Not Read Miranda Rights

Boston Marathon Suspect Not Read Miranda Rights

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 647 other followers

Blogs I Follow

I have been reading some interesting reports that Boston bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev is not being read his Miranda Rights and that he possibly will not be eligible for Miranda Rights at all. I want to talk a little bit about how scary this notion is.

Now don’t get me wrong, if he and his brother were truly the bombers, these scumbags need to pay. But he is technically an American Citizen, and deserves the same rights that each of us would get if we were arrested. The FBI released the reason why he wasn’t being read his rights with the following:

The public safety exception is triggered when police officers have an objectively reasonable need to protect the police or the public from immediate danger. Because the standard is objective, the availability of the exception does not depend on subjective motivation of the officers. Legitimate concerns for officer safety or public safety prompting unwarned custodial questioning arise in a variety of contexts. A common factor that can be gleaned from the courts addressing this issue is the prior knowledge or awareness of specific facts or circumstances that give rise to the imminent safety concern that prompted the questioning.

The public safety exception is usually used in terrorist situations where public safety must be made a priority. They need to find out if there are more bombs or if anyone else was involved. I understand that, and it is necessary. But it is scary to think that this can be implemented at any time.

Tsarnaev is technically an American citizen, and holds equals rights to all of us normal people. He is being denied his Miranda Rights and being held as a military prisoner. Also, if he is tried as a military combatant he will not be required to be appointed counsel in court. That means that an AMERICAN CITIZEN is denied legal representation according to our system of law.

That is some seriously bad juju. I am not a conspiracy theorist or some kind of Big Brother junky waiting for the government to take over. I just firmly believe in due process. What if we come to find out that, while these brothers may have been crazy, they did not commit the terrorist act accused of them.

We will have lawfully FALSELY TRIED A CITIZEN WITHOUT LEGAL COUNSEL.

That is some scary stuff. So while I agree that we need to know what information he has, and the interrogation team should work to find out as much as they can, I certainly think the proposition that you have no rights when you are accused of a terrorist act is a bit overwhelming.

If he is the killer, then all of this is justified. If he is not, then this will be a massive injustice that will forever scar the face of our nation. One of the reasons we founded this country was to stop this kind of behavior.

This also creates a precedent that anyone labeled a terrorist can have their rights revoked, regardless of nationality. Terrorism is a very subjective term, and can be used to do injustice to innocent people if mishandled.

I don’t like any instance of people getting rights taken away, crazy or not. It sets a bad standard for how we handle crises in the future.

I fear for the consequences these actions may have in the future, and how we will handle this type of situation should it arise again.

large

sources:

http://www.theatlanticwire.com/national/2013/04/dzhokhar-tsarnaev-miranda-warning/64406/

http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-bulletin/february2011/legal_digest

http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/19/4244802/boston-bombing-miranda-warning-put-on-hold-public-safety-exception

Advertisements

4 Comments

  1. The way the public safety exception works is police get to grill a suspect first about the specifics related to the exception, like “Are there any more bombs?” etc. They still have to give the Miranda after that, or none of the suspect’s testimony will be admissible. It’s just a time-saving, possibly life-saving technicality for emergency situations.

    • Yes I understand that, and I agree that this is useful and necessary in a situation such as this. But there is talk among conservative Congressmen that he will not be read his rights at all seeing that he committed a terrorist action against the U.S. because of his Islamic radicalism. Republicans want to try him in a military court without the requirement of counsel. I do not think the Obama administration will allow that, but the fact that we have people considering it is appalling. It goes against all of our due process standards. He is an American citizen, and is innocent until proven guilty. I do not blame the police officers, investigative team, or those who sanctioned the public safety exception for using it. It is necessary and could lead investigations into who may have sponsored these guys and if there are any more planted bombs anywhere. I just think that we, as a people, need to understand the ramifications of its implementation and the effects it could have further in our future should Trsarnaev not be given his rights at all.

      • I would share your concern about that, but those GOP guys aren’t in charge of it. The kid’s already in custody, the locals definitely don’t want him remanded, and I can’t understand under what conditions they would change that, pissing off a whole city that’s proud of having captured him. They’re already talking about the importance of getting a proper jury pool in Boston. They don’t even want a change of venue.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tweetastic

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

AAYC Blog

Amarillo Activity Youth Center

VentureBeat

News About Tech, Money and Innovation

Life + Times

Ellen's Saga of Friendship, Business, Growing Up, Love, and Trying to Make it in the World

Corporate Conspiracies

Essays&Articles

lennyesq

The Sienko Law Office

Jennifer Monje

Let's get started.

Poor David's Almanack

Ideas, Thoughts, and my take on all things communication as well as the technology that evolves it

usmanhashmi

Die Hard Supporter of PaK Sar Zameen Party

New York's PIX11 / WPIX-TV

New York News, Weather, Entertainment, Transit and More

maryraupublicrelations

Just another WordPress.com site

ESL Crystal

Teaching ESL and Planning a Conference

Novo Consultancy

Novo: to make anew, refresh, revive, change, alter, invent.

THE YOUNG MARKETER

A student's guide to marketing news, resources, tips & tricks on how to develop personal brand and separate yourself from the 99%.

Online Marketing

Your business, is our Business

Son of Sappho

Freelance Writer

Natacha Maheshe

Strive not to be a success, but rather to be of value - A. Einstein

Richard Bernich | Marketing Minute

The Official Guide to Marketing by Richard Bernich

Beyond PR

Engage Opportunity Everywhere

Tech

News and reviews from the world of gadgets, gear, apps and the web

%d bloggers like this: